HYSA CALC

High-Yield Savings Accounts Compared

A high-yield savings account pays many times what an ordinary bank savings account pays. The FDIC puts the national average for savings at 0.38% APY in its October 19, 2026figures, so the gap is worth real money on any balance. We do not print each bank’s rate on this page. Savings rates move without notice, and a figure that is a few weeks old can be wrong by a full percentage point. What we compare is the part that does not move: minimum balances, monthly fees, ATM access, how the rate is tiered, and FDIC cover. Every account links to the bank’s own rate page so you read today’s number at the source.

We last checked the fees, minimums and ATM access on this page against each bank’s own page on October 5, 2026. CIT Bank’s site would not load for us, so its details are as we last read them on August 23, 2026. We do not publish a bank’s APY here, because savings rates change without notice and a stale number is worse than none. Use the link by each account to see the rate the bank is paying right now. National averages come from the FDIC National Rates and Rate Caps.

How the links on this page work: They go directly to the provider, and we are paid nothing if you open an account. We hold no compensated relationship with any bank on this page today. We may add approved affiliate relationships later, and if we do this notice will say so and compensated links will be marked as sponsored. Either way the order of the list follows the published methodology, not a payout. How this site makes money.
High-yield savings accounts compared on fees, access and terms
#AccountRate structureMin. BalanceMonthly FeeATMFDICCurrent rate
1CIT Bank Platinum SavingsTiered by balance$5,000 for the top tier$0NoYesCheck
2Marcus by Goldman SachsOne rate at any balance$0$0NoYesCheck
3American Express High Yield SavingsOne rate at any balance$0$0NoYesCheck
4Capital One 360 Performance SavingsOne rate at any balance$0$0Branch only, not at an ATMYesCheck
5Synchrony High Yield SavingsOne rate at any balance$0$0Yes, with an optional ATM cardYesCheck

What happened to Discover Online Savings

Capital One completed its acquisition of Discover on 18 May 2025. Discover's savings page now redirects to Capital One 360 Performance Savings, and Discover describes itself as a division of Capital One, N.A. We could not find a page that says when Discover stopped taking new savings applications, so we do not state a date. We checked this on October 5, 2026. It is worth saying plainly because Discover still appears as an open option on a lot of comparison pages that have not been updated.

#1

CIT Bank Platinum Savings

FDIC insured · Min: $5,000 for the top tier · Fee: $0

Tiered by balance

Rate structure

Pros

  • No monthly fee
  • FDIC insured to $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per ownership category
  • Rate is usually near the top of the market

Cons

  • The headline rate needs a $5,000 balance
  • Below that threshold the rate drops steeply
  • No ATM card
  • We could not re-check CIT's terms on 5 October 2026: CIT's site would not load for us. These are as we last read them on 23 August 2026. Confirm the $5,000 tier on CIT's own page before you rely on it
#2

Marcus by Goldman Sachs

FDIC insured · Min: $0 · Fee: $0

One rate at any balance

Rate structure

Pros

  • No minimum balance
  • No monthly fee

Cons

  • No ATM card
  • Money leaves by transfer to another bank. Marcus says transfers of $100,000 or less made by 12 pm ET on a business day go out the same day
#3

American Express High Yield Savings

FDIC insured · Min: $0 · Fee: $0

One rate at any balance

Rate structure

Pros

  • No minimum balance
  • No monthly fee

Cons

  • No ATM card
  • No branch network
#4

Capital One 360 Performance Savings

FDIC insured · Min: $0 · Fee: $0

One rate at any balance

Rate structure

Pros

  • The only account here with physical branches
  • No minimum balance and no monthly fee

Cons

  • Rate has often trailed the online-only banks
#5

Synchrony High Yield Savings

FDIC insured · Min: $0 · Fee: $0

One rate at any balance

Rate structure

Pros

  • Offers an ATM card, which most online savings accounts do not
  • No minimum balance and no monthly fee

Cons

  • No branch network
  • No paired checking account

Other accounts we have checked

These accounts are not in the ranking above. We read their terms on each bank’s own page and list them here in A to Z order so you can compare them on the same facts. We print no rates.

How the links on this list work: They go directly to the provider, and we are paid nothing if you open an account. We hold no compensated relationship with any bank on this list today. We may add approved affiliate relationships later, and if we do this notice will say so and compensated links will be marked as sponsored. Either way the list stays in A to Z order, whatever a bank pays. How this site makes money.

Ally Bank Savings Account

  • Minimum to open: $0
  • Minimum balance: $0
  • Monthly fee: $0
  • Not stated by the bank. Ally's page says its money market account has a debit card and checks. It does not say the savings account has either.
  • Rate: Variable, with three balance tiers (under $5,000; $5,000 to $24,999.99; $25,000 and up). Ally says it currently pays the same APY on every tier. No direct-deposit condition. Ten limited withdrawals per statement cycle.
  • FDIC insured
Check today’s rate at Ally Bank

Terms read on the bank’s page on October 5, 2026.

Axos Summit Savings

  • Minimum to open: $0
  • Minimum balance: $0
  • Monthly fee: $0
  • ATM card on request. An ATM card is available on request, by secure message or in the app.
  • Rate: Tiered variable rate, no direct-deposit condition. Axos also advertises a new-customer rate boost for the first six statement cycles.
  • FDIC insured
Check today’s rate at Axos Bank

Terms read on the bank’s page on October 5, 2026.

Valley Direct High Yield Savings

  • Minimum to open: $1,000
  • Minimum balance: $0.01 to earn the advertised APY
  • Monthly fee: $0
  • Not stated by the bank. Withdrawals by transfer to another bank, Zelle, or a check the bank sends you on request.
  • Rate: Variable rate. New Valley customers with new money get a 12-month introductory rate of the standard rate plus 0.67 percentage points.
  • FDIC insured
Check today’s rate at Valley Direct

Terms read on the bank’s page on October 5, 2026.

What to do next

Want to know when the savings landscape changes?

We will email you when the Federal Reserve moves its target rate, when the FDIC publishes new national averages, and when we publish a newly verified comparison. We do not track individual banks’ APYs and we will not pretend to, so this is an infrequent email about things that genuinely change the picture.

Email only. We never send your calculator figures anywhere, they are worked out on your device. Every email has an unsubscribe link, and you can reply to any of them to come off the list.

Ready to see how much you will earn?

Enter any APY above into the calculator and see your 5-year growth.

Open the HYSA Calculator

Frequently asked questions

Which high-yield savings account pays the most?

It changes, often monthly, so any figure printed on a comparison page goes out of date quickly. That is why we link to each bank's own rate page instead of publishing a number. What is stable is the shape of each offer. CIT Bank pays its headline rate only above a $5,000 balance, while Marcus, American Express, Capital One and Synchrony pay one rate at any balance. Check the tier rules before the headline number, because a tiered account can pay very little on a small balance.

What is a good APY for a high-yield savings account?

Compare it against the national average rather than against a fixed target. The FDIC put the average savings rate at 0.38% APY in its October 19, 2026 figures, and the average money market rate at 0.63%. A competitive online savings account pays several times that. If an account pays anywhere near the national average it is not really a high-yield account, whatever it is called.

Are these banks safe?

Yes. All five accounts are FDIC insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per bank. FDIC insurance is backed by the U.S. government and has never failed to pay a covered depositor.

How often do these rates change?

Banks can change HYSA rates at any time. Rates usually move within weeks of a Federal Reserve rate decision. Check the bank's rate page before you open the account.

Can I switch HYSAs later if I find a higher rate?

Yes. Closing a HYSA does not trigger a CD-style early-withdrawal penalty, though individual banks can set their own closure, transfer or dormancy rules. Many savers move money to whichever bank has the top rate at the moment. The downside is the paperwork of opening and closing accounts.

Do HYSAs charge monthly fees?

None of the five accounts above charge monthly fees. Some traditional banks charge $5 to $15 per month for savings accounts, but online HYSAs almost never do.

What is the catch with HYSAs?

There is no catch on the safety side. The rate is variable, so the APY can drop later. Most HYSAs do not offer checks or debit cards, so they work best as a place to grow savings, not for daily spending.

How we ranked these accounts

We order accounts by how well they suit a saver holding an ordinary balance, weighing minimum balance gates, monthly fees, ATM access and whether the rate is tiered. We do not rank by APY, because we do not publish APYs: rates move without notice and we have no maintained feed that would keep a figure honest between updates. Each account links to the bank’s own rate page instead. The methodology page has full math transparency. Primary data sources: FDIC monthly national rates and each bank's published rate page.